Home > News > Scottish ministers refuse to confirm if King asked for rent freeze bill changes

Scottish ministers refuse to confirm if King asked for rent freeze bill changes

Scottish ministers have rejected calls to confirm whether King Charles III asked for changes to a Scottish rent freeze bill that could affect tenancies on his Highland estate.

The Scottish Liberal Democrats wanted to change an emergency bill that is being rushed through Holyrood and will freeze rents for private tenants in Scotland for six months in response to the cost of living crisis.

Their amendment, which fell by 22 votes to 93, called on ministers to disclose whether the King used his opaque powers, known in Scotland as crown consent, to seek changes to the bill, to disclose whether there had been any discussions about its objectives with the King’s lawyers, and to discover what ministers did as a result of those alleged discussions.

King Charles has private tenants on his estate at Balmoral, but his late mother, Queen Elizabeth II, did not object to similar Scottish government measures introduced to freeze rents during the Covid crisis in 2020.

The Lib Dems’ proposals were backed by Scottish Labour, which sign that MSPs are becoming increasingly unhappy about the ministers’ refusal to disclose if, when and how the monarch has tried to influence legislation.

The Guardian revealed last year that ministers in Edinburgh allowed the Queen to vet at least 67 bills that affected her personal property and public powers under the arcane rule inherited from Westminster. According to the rule, such bills need to secure the monarch’s consent before they can be passed by the Scottish parliament.

Alex Cole-Hamilton, the Scottish Liberal Democrat leader, told MSPs on Wednesday evening the public interest case for greater transparency about the King’s role was clear. As this was the first piece of Scottish legislation the King had been asked to consent to, it was an ideal opportunity for the monarch and ministers to become more open, Cole-Hamilton said.

“Transparency and scrutiny are pillars of our democracy,” he added. “They have indeed been championed by our new King, and parliament has the opportunity tonight to agree upon the principle. I believe people have a right to know when changes [have] happened because of discussions between ministers and the crown.”

HICH LTD has continually raised the quality standards in the UK property survey market. Our multi-award-winning property survey service has made us the leading reference in the property survey market.

We offer property survey services of the highest quality. Using state-of-the-art equipment, we provide top-notch property surveys at affordable prices. Our prices are based on the number of rooms rather than the value of the properties, so you will always get the best value for money with our services.

Please look at our Trustpilot page and see why customers have chosen us as their favourite property survey provider!

At HICH LTD, we work to serve our clients and make the world a better place for everyone. We actively collaborate with NGOs to promote environmental, social and charitable causes. If you want to know more about our efforts or how you can help, contact us at hichinfo@aol.co.uk.

HICH LTD extends a warm invitation to contractors and service providers throughout the UK to join our network; by joining the Contractors and Service Providers Network, you will enjoy benefits such as a significant increase in customer flow, advertising on our high-traffic website, and direct contact with thousands of customers in your zip area. Find more information here or by following the QR code in the following video.